The Pros and Cons of Making Your Own Sunscreen

The Pros and Cons of Making Your Own Sunscreen

Introduction
For eco-conscious skincare lovers, crafting a natural sunscreen at home can feel like a rewarding step toward cleaner beauty. Our Natural Mineral Sunscreen Balm Guide offers a handcrafted formula using non-nano zinc oxide, organic rosehip oil, shea butter, and beeswax for a nourishing, reef-safe alternative to commercial sunscreens.

But is making your own sunscreen the right choice? Let’s explore the pros, cons, chemicals you avoid, and potential dangers of homemade sunscreens to help you decide.

Pros of Handcrafted Sunscreen

  1. Control Over Ingredients Making your own sunscreen lets you choose organic, high-quality ingredients like shea butter, jojoba oil, and rosehip oil, which hydrate and soothe while offering minor UV protection. You can tailor the formula to sensitive skin, making it potentially safe for babies over 6 months (with a pediatrician’s approval).
  2. Avoid Harmful Chemicals Commercial sunscreens often contain chemical filters like oxybenzone, avobenzone, or octinoxate, which may disrupt hormones, irritate skin, or harm marine ecosystems. A handcrafted formula with non-nano zinc oxide provides physical UV protection without these risks, ensuring a reef-safe product.
  3. Eco-Friendly and Customizable Homemade sunscreens are often water-free, eliminating the need for synthetic preservatives like parabens. You can package your balm in reusable glass or silicone, reducing waste. Plus, you can tweak the texture or add nourishing oils like rosehip for a personalized touch.
  4. Cost-Effective Creativity Sourcing ingredients online (e.g., Amazon, iHerb) allows you to make multiple batches at a fraction of the cost of premium natural sunscreens. Our digital guide simplifies the process, turning sun protection into a fun, crafty project for eco-conscious families.

Cons of Handcrafted Sunscreen

  1. Uncertain SPF Protection Unlike commercial sunscreens, homemade formulas aren’t lab-tested. Our guide uses ~20% non-nano zinc oxide for an estimated SPF 30+, but uneven mixing or application can reduce effectiveness, leaving skin vulnerable to UV damage.
  2. Time and Skill Required Crafting sunscreen requires precision—sanitizing tools, measuring ingredients, and blending for a smooth texture. Mistakes like poor zinc dispersion can weaken protection, and the process can be time-consuming compared to buying ready-made products.
  3. Shelf Life and Stability Without preservatives, natural oils like rosehip can oxidize, shortening shelf life (6-12 months, refrigerated). Contamination during preparation is a risk, potentially causing skin irritation if the product spoils.

Chemicals You Avoid
By making your own sunscreen, you skip potentially harmful chemicals found in some commercial products:

  • Oxybenzone and Octinoxate: Linked to hormone disruption and coral reef damage.
  • Parabens: Preservatives that may mimic estrogen and irritate sensitive skin.
  • Artificial Fragrances: Common allergens that can cause reactions, especially in babies.
  • Homosalate and Octocrylene: Chemical filters with potential environmental and health concerns. Our guide’s formula uses only natural ingredients like zinc oxide and organic oils, offering a gentler, eco-friendly alternative.

Dangers of Homemade Sunscreen

  1. Inadequate UV Protection The American Academy of Dermatology warns that homemade sunscreens often fail to provide sufficient UVA/UVB protection due to inconsistent formulations. This increases risks of sunburn, premature aging, and skin cancer, especially for babies with delicate skin.
  2. Allergic Reactions Even natural ingredients like rosehip oil can cause sensitivities in some users. Without patch-testing, you risk irritation, particularly on infants. Always consult a pediatrician before using on babies over 6 months, and prioritize shade for those under 6 months.
  3. Regulatory and Safety Risks Homemade sunscreens aren’t FDA-approved, and claiming specific SPF levels without testing can mislead users. Contamination from unsanitized tools or improper storage can lead to bacterial growth, posing additional skin risks.

Conclusion
Crafting your own sunscreen with our Natural Mineral Sunscreen Balm Guide is a rewarding way to embrace natural skincare, avoid harmful chemicals, and create a reef-safe product. However, the risks—uncertain SPF, time investment, and potential instability—mean it’s not a full replacement for lab-tested sunscreens.

For best results, pair your handcrafted balm with shade, hats, and protective clothing. Ready to try it?
Download our digital guide and start your eco-friendly skincare journey today!

Get the Natural Mineral Sunscreen Balm Guide from our Shopify store! It includes everything you need to craft a 150 ml batch of nourishing, baby-safe sunscreen. Join the natural beauty movement and protect your skin sustainably!

Back to blog